Headcanon: Imagine Teddy Lupin's teachers looking at the list of upcoming students and being like, "Oh, Lupin! Remus was a good student, despite what he may have gotten into with his friends, his son should be no real trouble" now imagine eleven-year-old Teddy jumping off of the stool after being sorted and his hair turning his House colors and everyone simultaneously remembers who his mother was
Teddy Lupin - I don't agree with Vic's and Dom's houses but otherwise this is great
The Marauders were definitely McGonagall's favorite students, especially James. Dude may have been a bit arrogant, but he was brilliant at the two things McGonagall loved most - Quidditch and Transfiguration.