Cheddar Bay Biscuits Recipe from The Food Charlatan! These Cheddar Bay Biscuits taste just like the ones from Red Lobster! Packed with cheddar cheesy goodness, with a little (tiny) bit of heat. The baked biscuits are brushed with garlic butter. You can make this recipe into drop biscuits (which is so easy), but I love rolling them out and cutting them to get all those flaky layers! Either way they are tender, moist, and oh so cheesy! Garlic, parsley, cayenne, cheddar, oh my!